The Sandbox Campaign

I've been doing a lot of reading recently, re-learning how to GM and prepare adventures. Over the years I got into the habit of having no preparation beyond a general idea of the plan and a book from which to pull names. Thoughts and plans are beginning to coalesce and today I've been pondering Campaigns.

I used to run very structured campaigns. One directly related adventure led into another until we reached the conclusion. I adjusted on the way to account for player actions etc., I've always tried hard not to railroad my players and never decided ahead of time how a campaign should end. However, there weren't a lot of (almost any) side quests. Then, over time, I switched to a Sandbox approach, building worlds and letting my players have the run of the place. I love this type of game but without the driving motivation of a campaign, many of my players lost interest.

Now, after years of life getting in the way, some reading and some thinking, I'm moving towards a blending of the two. Something I should have done ages ago but ... well, never mind why I didn't. The important thing is result. Blending a Strict Campaign with a Sandbox Game. I imagine what this will look like is a Sandbox setting where the players can pursue their own goals etc. if they choose. There will be a "main campaign" over-all but the buildup to it will be more gradual. A clue here, an encounter there, with plenty of miscellaneous adventures in between. Each miscellaneous adventure will be designed to further one or more goals, curiosities, what-have-you that the player's might express. Eventually, the clues and encounters of the over-arching campaign will reach a critical mass (primarily player-driven) and while the Sandbox will still be there, the adventures will be increasingly (and then primarily) directly related to The Campaign.

As I said, at what point this critical mass will occur is uncertain. It's entirely dependent on whether the players become increasingly invested in the connections between the clues and encounters they experience. In theory the players could remain invested only in their own goals and The Campaign will never happen. It's entirely dependent on whether the players I have at the time, or those that you have, if you use this method, have personal goals or are more interested in pursuing the clues. Because it's a Sandbox setting, if The Campaign "flops" there will still be consequences. Whatever the protagonist was planning will likely succeed without PC intervention and this itself may lead to another new campaign opportunity.

What do you think? Do you already use this method in your games? How well does it work, how do your players respond to it? If you don't already use it, do you think your players would latch onto the clues presented or ignore them in favor of their own goals?

No comments:

Post a Comment