As I near the completion of phase two writing on Renaissance I have spent quite a bit of time considering what to include in the initial book and what should be sectioned off as GM's material or supplemental material. In particular, I've gone back and forth on whether to include an appendix with alternate rules for HP vs. Wounds or whether I should release an HP supplement once the beta testing is done.
Let's look at the first issue, HP vs. Wounds. When I first started working on 2nd edition Renaissance I wanted to get away from Hit Points. I didn't dislike them, specifically, but I didn't feel that they were appropriately representative of the style of game I was building. When character's have Hit Points, they can get to a point where they amass so many that they throw caution to the wind and combat becomes less dangerous (almost negligibly so for some). This is something I wanted to avoid. I wanted to make sure that combat was always a dangerous risk. I achieved that with Wounds.
With Wounds, a character or creature can still get to a point where they have high survivability in combat due simply to how tough they are. They can ignore or shrug off some degree of injury. However, over all, when you go into combat, you know that one of the two of you (you or your opponent) is going to be dead or retreating in the next few rounds and until you achieve that supreme toughness, it's usually a fair bet either way. Such risk in combat encourages players to maneuver for advantage more actively rather than just wading in since even a single hit could potentially turn the tide of battle.
This is what I wanted to achieve and so far in my alpha testing stages it's worked really well. This same effect can be achieved with Hit Points but when a player looks at their sheet and sees Hit Points, I find that their first impulse is to treat their character with a little less caution. However, Hit Points do have a place. They are important to certain types of gameplay which, until you get burnt out on it, is also a lot of fun. Renaissance is essentially a game of high fantasy** but with Wounds instead of Hit Points it takes on a more visceral feel than your standard high fantasy game. This is what I was aiming for, a more "realistic" high fantasy setting.
But, true high fantasy is also lots of fun and I don't want to remove it entirely as an option. So, I thought it would be nice to include an HP option in an appendix in the main book. As I near the end of this stage of design and writing, however, I feel like there is too much that I'm trying to include in the primary manual so I'm working on paring it down to the necessities of play. I may revise my opinion depending on the feedback from the beta tests this coming year but at the moment I'm planning on releasing the HP alternative as a supplement. Probably as a free pdf download as well as a bound booklet, similar in size to a published adventure, with as minimal a cost as possible to cover printing, supplies and shipping.
**though in my testing and from what my players have told me of their own games it can be easily re-configured to any genre - sci-fi, western, modern, horror, etc.
No comments:
Post a Comment