I was running through the spell lists this morning, searching in particular for any necromancy spells because I couldn't remember if or how many I had included. There aren't a ton, but there are a reasonable number to spark the interest and research of budding necromancers. However, what I also discovered was that I had several different spells that did the same thing. Suddenly it occurred to me that this was a much more effective editing practice for games than the standard proof reading style.
In the past, I've edited my games by simply reading through the materials. However, the drawback I had with my last published system (1st edition Renaissance) was that in one part of the book the mechanic would make sense and flow well but then, later on, I would come across a different mechanic for the same element. However, since they were an hour or more apart in my reading I didn't remember that the mechanic was different from before. I only knew that it worked in that one place in the manual and, since I wrote both, it wasn't jarring to see the older mechanic still in the text. In this case, instead of finding that there were multiple versions of a mechanic, I found that I was re-using the same mechanics in different spell so that only the names were different. Obviously this was unintentional.
So, how to avoid and correct this. Well, avoiding it in the initial writing may not be possible, but that's what editing is for. However, how can I avoid missing it when editing? If I just read straight through the text, I probably won't catch it since I'm not likely to edit the whole thing in a single sitting. Thankfully, the discovery of the issue also led to the discovery of the solution.
Instead of doing a straight read through to edit the mechanics (it's still the best method for editing for spelling, grammar and readability) I will do a preliminary index of all places where a particular mechanic is referenced and then check each one in full before moving on to the next mechanic. In this way, I can ensure uniformity of method throughout all instances of the same mechanic. Yes, it'll be long and arduous but it's better than ending up with the same mechanic using a different method in two different places (like shields giving AC in one place and giving DR in another!).
In the case of spells, powers, etc. I'll have to build a matrix of spells and their types/supporting formulas to make the editing easier. Naturally this too will increase the editing time BUT it will also make it easier in the future to release spell supplements without duplicating past effects.
I hope this discovery helps you in your own editing! Perhaps you were already familiar with it and this is old hat to you. Perhaps you have other editing techniques that you've found are useful. If so, please share them in the comments section, I'm always open to new ideas on how to ease and improve the workload for a project.
No comments:
Post a Comment